Home Blog Page 1604

Open Content Methodology and Subject-Oriented Educational Environment

Valery S. Meskov

Professor
UNESCO
MVS947@YANDEX.RU

e-Learning is perceived as a new word in pedagogical science and practice, a way of overcoming of crisis of education in all its manifestations. However, technological solutions influence on the organisational aspects of training, allowing making educational processes more flexible and focused on the user. But as usual in the basis of e-learning system still lay traditional pedagogies build on a paradigm of transmitting of knowledge and cultural samples, conceptually rooted in ‘The Great Didactics’ (1657) by Jan Amos Komenski (Comenius). 

Post-non-classical methodology

There is a correlation between the level of social development and dominant methodologies. The transition to the next level is accompanied by the paradigmatic transformation of methodology. The methodology corresponding to the Industrial Society is a classical methodology, ‘classical picture of the universe’… but an integrated picture of the universe could not be shaped when taking into account the existence only of the macrocosm and microcosm and not considering presence of the world of information (Infoworld).

Knowledge with which the educational theory and practice operates is the same information which is somehow transferred, structured and created by Subjects during inter-subject interaction and/or through a cultural layer (and education, as it known, is a part of culture). For this reason, in order to understand the post-non-classical approach to education it is necessary to consider at least three central points: a challenge of the Subject’s destination; role of the environments surrounding the Subject, including society and its concrete varieties; and conditions for the subject-to-subject interaction.

Society as Environment and mediator

In general case, we, in our capacity  of possible Subjects (or differentiator of inner and external), always find ourselves plunged into some environment which is per se a specific exemplification of the Holistic World. Socium and all its professional and social areas (including education) exist as such environments and exemplifications.

The question is to which extent the Subject can see the subjectiveness of the Holistic World through a concrete, formed, or designed environment? If this extent were equal to zero, the subjectiveness of the Subject itself would stay indistinguishable. Subjectiveness is a property imparted by a Subject to some components of the environment, which interact with it, or the environment as a whole (i.e. the whole world). The Subject’s inclusion into the Picture of the World means not only the inclusion of a person into all observed processes but also the inclusion of the other part of interaction, namely of the World as a Subject. The environment (including such as societies) serves as their meeting point and mediator.

Object-oriented environment and normative educational paradigm

Both Industrial and Consumer  Societies are unaware about a  human being as a Subject and the World as well as about their ‘middle’ position. Knowledge about a human being is unimportant for them. In this sense, the Industrial and Consumer Societies are rather Objects than Subjects. In both Societies, the  borders of the socium are the borders  of the World. Hence, the aims of the mass education systems of these societies exist within the range from pragmatics to socialization. These societies have no need in Subjects and they lean not on Subjects (and World) but on norms and  hierarchy of prescribed relations  that allow the elite to govern/
manage the non-subject majority  of people, organisations and productions.

Below, there are several characteristics of the Industrial and Consumer  Societies given in correspondence to the aspects mostly general and important  for a Subject.

Industrial society

  • Observable Reality: Description of Macroworld (without a Subject)
  • Used methodology: Classical methodology (methodology of classical/natural science)
  • Human Role/Image: Person as a mechanism (mechanical clock) – Worker.

Consumer society

  • Observable Reality: Description of Microworld (with a Subject as a Recipient, Consumer and Observer)
  • Used methodology: Non-classical methodology
  • Human Role/Image: Person as an organism (algorithmic model) – Consumer and Observer.

These types of socium are object-focused, and the object-focused and normative educational paradigm corresponds to it. Such a paradigm generates a normative educational environment, which is oriented to socialization and implies strictly limited roles for conditioned and externally motivated actors.

Educational Paradigm for the Industrial and Consumer Societies: Object-oriented Type

  • Mass Education Strategy: Embodying an individual into society (socialization, unification, loyalty of a human being)
  • Social Role Training: Worker, Consumer, Observer
  • Principals: From Jan Amos Komenski (Comenius)  (‘educational conveyor’)
  • Educational Environment: Prescriptive and normative

The normative environment pushes out a Subject and determines it externally inn such a way that a Subject is ‘reduced’ (diminished) to a sum of normalizing parameters and correspondingly to the normative interactions.

Route of Subject’s Coming-into-being 

A human being as a Subject exists to the extent of the completeness of its individual Picture of the World. He/she comprehends the World and him/herself indirectly, through activities, observation and reasoning. The validity ofeach separate conclusion can be estimated through comparison with all others through finding of cognitive integrity inherent only in the
human being.

The human being is compelled to seek for integrity within intra-subject continuing formation of him/herself via cognitive activities expressed in dynamic redefinition of structural  limits of ‘Ego’ (‘myself’) and, accordingly, of the Holistic World.  This is his/her internal reason (cause)  of activity.

The Subject is a possible, continuously becoming but never the completed project. In reality, the Subject’s route is hardly so direct and smooth. However, on  the Subject’ way from ‘folded’ to ‘unfolded’ state there is an important spot where a person finds out the evidence of existence of him/herself in its capacity of a Subject and, consequently, the evidence of existence of the World as the Subject. This spot (more precisely – event) which figuratively refers to as ‘Second birth’ is a point of transition from the ‘Object being’ to ‘Subject being’, that is subjective self-identification, both internal and external.

Hence for the Holistic World. Education as a part of the World should serve, first, to the World, and only after that to its particular incarnations that themselves require the coordination of their purposes with the interests of the Holistic World. Education should be shifted from social-oriented to world-oriented one.

Subject-oriented educational environment and new educational paradigm

The post-non-classical Picture of the World assumes an ‘uneliminated’ inclusion of the Subject in it that requires the adequate use of concept of environment. In this context, environment is a dynamic set of the opportunities identified by the Subject in only cases when it has a corresponding value motivation and the concepts of environment and Subject have complimentary relations. The Subject can only be found within an environment. The only Subject can define (and interpret) the boundary between itself and environment, i.e. between the senses ‘inside’ and senses ‘outside’ (or inner senses andexternal senses).The post-non-classical methodology claims that the Subjects cannot interact directly, and this interaction is always carried out via an environment. The environment operates as a carrier of certain properties and opportunities that can be transferred to the Subject and expressed through the competences. In case of education, the necessary degree of coherence of the environment and the Subject can be articulated within the framework of the competency approach according to which a competence constitutes a generated multivariate fixed image determining one’s ability to be engaged in some professional or social practices.

The inclusion of only one Subject into the environment imparts it a property of subjectiveness.

  • What the subject-oriented environment transmits?
  • From the denotat’s point of view: forms.
  • From the designat’s point of view: senses.
  • From the professional point of view: competences.
  • From the Subject’s point of view: subjectiveness.

The basic, fundamental distinction between e-learning and any others concepts of mass educational practices is the following: e-learning exists and functions within a specific environment with a potential to educate. e-Learning environment contains a set (in the 21st century increasing in quality and quantity) of educational opportunities which can be found, identified and acquired by the Subject in course of personal interaction with environment. Properly designed e-learning environment allows accumulating, generalizing and radiating subjectiveness required for transformation of ‘Ego’ in its capacity of Subject and thus assumes the roles of the Teacher.

In contrast to earlier mentioned characteristic features of Industrial and Consumer Societies, the Knowledge-based Societies should possess not simply other but fundamentally new characteristics:
The coherence of the Subject and environment in narrow and wider
sense attributes to new educational paradigm some exemplifications of which can be observed in e-learning practices of the latest
generation (e.g. developed with Web 2.0). We suggest the motto for new education: ‘Embodying an Individual into the World through embodying the World into an Individual’. (Note: embodying into the World, not only into a community/
social group!).

Subjectiveness via competences: roles of actors in Subject-oriented educational environments

Each subject-oriented environment promotes the Subject’s coming into being (birth). The educational environment is intendedfor doing this massively, and tuned for the Subject’s transformation, which is its professional competence. The environment has this competence because it possesses properties of stretching, storage, accumulation and translation of the competences, which belong to the Subjects (in our case of the learners), included inthe environment. Thus, the environment becomes the carrier ofthe Subjects’ competences and realizes  their interaction.A competence is described as readiness to some activities, which combines knowledge, skills, motivation, necessary experience, personal characteristics and ethical ground rules for activities. The readiness holy belongs to a Subject. The transition to a model of competences means in practice a long-expected inclusion of a Subject into the Picture of Educational World.

Acquiring of a competence is a result of the dynamic interaction of a Subject with the educational environment. A Subject and the environment undergo transformation throughout this multifaceted process. A degree of the transformation could not be measured (by anyone and by anything) but could be assessed to the Subject (and not to the environment).

According to the European model of the competences as well to the findings of Russian researches, the basis of all professional, social, cultural and (inter) personal competences consists of basic (humanitarian) competences:

  • Motivation for self-development and activity of a Subject;
  • Development of thinking and intellect, coming to Open Mind;
  • Communicative competences, openness and benevolence;
  • Creative competences, respect for cultures, creativity, history, religions, traditions, etc.

The competence model allows clinching an old argument on priorities by giving the priority to education as upbringing and not as training. What is more, this model regards the Subject’s transformation as a crucial prerequisite for upbringing/education of a person as a member of the Knowledge Society. Via the gaining the competences the educational environment pilots a learner to the birth of a Subject, i.e. to the forming of a holistic image of himself/herself. This forming conforms to the initial meaning of the word ‘formation’ (in many languages relevant to ‘education’).

Taking into account our model of roles and functions of the educational environment, we must adjoin to former roles some new ones, namely those which are related to the level of a Subject and serve for upbringing and ‘obstetrics’ during the actualization of the Subject: from a possibility – through the ‘Second birth’ – to a manifested and maximally completely realized one.
The first three (normative) functions do not require the participation of a Subject and can be realized by an environment itself.

Roles of actors in educational paradigm and properties of educational environment of Subject-oriented practice

Subject-oriented educational environments potentially exist and always have, but the system of mass education formed by the moment leave the issues concerning a Subject, its transformation and (worldview) behind the area of its activities, and this situation is unacceptable for the Knowledge Societies.

The task of forming for a Subject of the mass, accessible and open environment may be accomplished with e-learning. However, in the case of design of such environment with the use of the object-oriented methodology a normative educational environment is trivially produced. The post-non-classical methodology (for example the open content methodology) allows forming the subject-oriented educational environment of e-learning adequate to the Knowledge Societies.

The mentioned environment has a property of stretching, stocking, accumulating and translation the competences of included in it teaching and learning Subjects. The environment turns into bearer of their subjectiveness and in such a way obtains the abilities (competences) of a Teacher. Such environment gains the properties of atmosphere, ‘nutrient medium’ which promotes the included Subjects’ coming-to-being and develops into more and more sophisticated. At the same time it undergoes transformation by way of each subject-to-subject interaction.

Open content: exemplification of Subject-oriented educational environment

The post-non-classical methodology is a generalized theoretical concept. However, the true exemplification of it may be found in some virtual community practices under name of open content and open source projects.In the narrow sense, the Open Content means digital content under the specific (open) regime of using, usually regulated by the special open license for dissemination of content. But the concept ‘content’ must have not so primitive exploration. In Post-non-classical Paradigm, the content as a Sequence (collection) of Subject-organized senses indissoluble with carriers will play a key role.

In the broader sense, the concept ‘open content’ (or simply Content) constitutes a holistic virtual milieu, which includes:

  • An environment of the virtual (third) culture
  • Individuals as Subjects of interaction with this environment
  • Individuals as Subjects of interaction with each other within this EnvironmentProcesses and products of mentioned interactions

In place of a conclusion

As it mentioned above, historically education in many cultures/languages was equal to formation. Though since the middle of the 18th century one may track the tendency towards interpretation of education as a process of building of a person ‘on the inside’ or its ‘self-formation’, all systems of mass education were shaped for producing of ‘useful members of society’ (whether it be a social group, either a community, or working team, etc.). In such systems the process of the Subject’s coming-into-being takes place spontaneously, sometimes it may correlate with educational procedures (lucky is a learner in this case!) but often it is in conflict with them (in this case both learner and teacher are unhappy).

The modern teachers were brought up and act now in a paradigm of professional school of the classical type, and it could be difficult for them to get used to an idea that the education system instead of polished through centuries translation of knowledge should intervene in the most complicated intrapersonal processes which can’t be assessed with any external criteria. Modern systems of mass education and educational environments are also created mostly in the old style scarcely corresponding to contemporary challenges and still are resistance to any modification or simply inert.

Considering education via a prism of the post-non-classical approach one may find that the sense (or core) of education should be a Subject’s coming-into-being. The Open Content experience of last years has shown possible handling with the unsettled problems mentioned above. The open content environment is a subject-oriented environment, and new open content methodology (as post-non-classical one) applied to e-Learning theory and practice could and should advance mass education towards meeting the Knowledge Societies challenges

Kenya&rsquo:s University of Nairobi

The University of Nairobi is a pioneer institution in university education in Kenya and in the region. Established in 1956, the university has upheld its tradition of delivering diversified academic programmes and specialisations in sciences, technology, humanities, social sciences and arts. Currently the University has developed and evolved approximately 200 education programmes that are disseminated across the seven campuses located in the capital city of Nairobi, Kenya.

Far cry from the earliest years when the University was transformed from the existing Royal Technical College into the second University College in East Africa, in 1961 under the name, Royal College Nairobi. The University began preparing students in its Faculties of Arts, Science and Engineering for degrees of the University of London. Other faculties, such as the Faculty of Special Professional Studies (later called the Faculty of Commerce) and Faculty of Architecture offered diplomas for qualifications of professional bodies/institutions.

On May 1964, the Royal College Nairobi was renamed University College of Nairobi, and was designated a constituent college of the inter-territorial Federal University of East Africa. This meant that the degrees awarded were of the University of East Africa and not of the University of London. Come 1970, the University College Nairobi underwent another transformation and emerged as the first national University in Kenya. However, another change was in the offing, which saw the University renamed as the University of Nairobi.

In 1983, the University restructured itself in order to decentralize administrative facilities by creating six campus colleges headed by individual principals. These are:

  • College of Agriculture & Veterinary Sciences (Upper Kabate Campus)
  • College of Architecture & Engineering (Main Campus)
  • College of Biological & Physical Sciences (Chiromo Campus)
  • College of Education & External Studies (Kikuyu Campus)
  • College of Health Sciences (Kenyatta National Hospital Campus)
  • College of Humanities & Social Sciences (Main Campus)

    From its inception in the 1960s, the University has expanded exponentially in terms of the number of students, staff and physical facilities. From about 2,580 undergraduate students and 184 postgraduate students in the 1970-71 academic year, to its current population of 36,000 students, 7,000 of which are postgraduate students pursuing their studies. In the same manner, the number of teaching staff has increased to 1,330 and an administrative and support staff of about 4,000. Over 90,000 graduates have passed through the University of Nairobi.

    The academic streams offered by the University of Nairobi have contributed significantly to the high-level training requirements of human resources in Kenya and Africa. Besides traditional areas, highly specialised areas such as Agricultural Science, Diplomacy and International Relations, Development Studies and Mass Communication are some of the areas not catered to by any other educational institution of higher learning in the country and the region. These addition of a continuing education or module II degree, diploma and certificate programmes has opened up the option of learning for those Kenyans, and even non-Kenyans who are not able to secure admission in the University itself due to limited places in the module I degree programmes.

    The rules and regulations for the module II programmes are the same as those for the the module I programmes. All very much in keeping with the University mission statement:  A centre for learning and scholarship; preparing students for academic pursuits, professional development, enhanced personal lives and responsible global citizenship; extending the frontiers of knowledge through research, creative works, and scholarship; fostering an intellectual culture that bridges theory with practise; contributing to social, economic, and cultural development; and through intellectual products, enhances the quality of life of the people of Kenya and all humanity.

    In fact, the core of the University’s offerings has been the intent to serve society through the transfer of intellectual and branded products to meet the changing needs of society through collaborations with industry, academic and professional fields in the search for solutions. An example of which would be the various international academic links and exchange programmes which number over a hundred. Also, on the list of academic initiatives is the Institute of Tropical & Infectious Diseases, which was jointly set up with the University of Manitoba. Other combined initiatives with the National Defence College and the Kenya college of Communications Technology have also been set up.

    Besides these, the University has not overlooked with the emergent need  for information technologies and ICT, with the inclusion of a School for Computing and Infomatics, the only national-level computer science school in Kenya that also trains computer scientists at the postgraduate and research levels.

    Recent developments world over have not left the University unaffected, as an outcome of the performance contract signed with the Government of Kenya, the University has started moving towards ISO certification, later this year. In order for the University to acquire certification, various training programmes have been launched, corresponding to the goals set in the performance contract, in the areas of:

    • Pedagogical training
    • Health and safety awareness
    • Customer service
    • Results-based management
    • ISO-certification training

    On the technological front, the University has increased it’s bandwidth and re-launched the University website (www.uonibi.ac.ke) with increased content available online. The University has invested heavily on ICT infrastructure. Many of the functions are now automated, more computer labs, processing of marks and transcripts is faster and information is readily available. Other efforts are also on to rework the student-to-PC ratios.

Digital, ‘Highly Connected’ Children: Implications for Education

In the past decades tremendous digital-technological innovations have flooded our lives. The impact of these inventions on socialisation, ways of thinking, and modes of learning, is far reaching. The new digital technologies challenge many of our concepts and beliefs and make new demands on us as to understanding the new high-tech, digital culture .In order to do so one has to be skilled in digital literacy.

According to Yoram Eshet-Alkalai, a scholar from the Tel- Hai College in Israel, the new digital literacy is penta componental. These five cognitive thinking strategies can help the perplexed:

  • Photo-visual literacy
  • Reproduction Literacy
  • Lateral Multi-directional Literacy
  • Information Literacy
  • Socio-Emotional Literacy

Let me elaborate on each of these components:

Photo-Visual Literacy

If we look for example at our computer desktop, at out car panel or at the cellular phone, we’ll see that they all give us iconic information. These  photo –visual signs serve as shortcuts  for action and do away with the mediation of the cognitive skill of deciphering and understanding the alphabetic symbols.The use of emotics e.g.; ? ;-),(-: and the shortened Internet writing such as b4b and cu,  all emphasise the tendency to break away from the traditional, alphabetic writing.

Reproduction Literacy

Reproduction Literacy could be likened to what John Kao (The Art and Discipline of Corporate Creativity, HarperBusiness,1996) calls jamming: ‘taking a topic, a question, an idea, disseminate it, break it, manipulate  it, and reassemble it…creating
something new.’

In the information world, an enormous amount of information and spiritual creations are ‘out there’ in cyberspace. Billions of pages carrying artistic work, articles, essays, music and graphics, can be accessed and made use of. We are therefore, faced with a new challenge  to use these existing spiritual treasures in innovative ways, thus creating new concepts and forms.

Lateral literacy
A strategy much needed for deciphering and navigating in the new digital literacy, is lateral- multi-directional thinking. This literacy marks a shift from the more structured, well planned traditional book-like literacy. Unlike the closely structured book environment in which the amount of information and the order of presenting the information are predefined, the net environment is open to rearrangement. Linear structures following sequential logic, give room to non-linear, hypertext, associative structures. On one hand, this loose structure fosters creativity and is open to new creations and interpretations, on the other hand the new open-ended exploratory environment is dynamic and even chaotic.
New cognitive skills are needed in order to navigate freely, yet mindfully among the many sites, and from site to site, while using the hypertext. The ability to focus, as well as integrative and summative skills are necessary in order to reconstruct knowledge out of huge chunks of information arrived at in an unstructured manner.

Information literacy

Another problem, we are faced with is that of reliability: how do we know that what we read, saw or heard comes from a reliable source? How do we evaluate the information gleaned?

Yoram Eshet suggests a cognitive tool in order to cope with this problem: Information Literacy: Trust nobody. This literacy acts as a filter: “It identifies false, irrelevant, or biased information, and avoids its penetration into the learner’s cognition…. without a good command of information literacy, how can one decide which, of the endless pieces of contradicting information found on the web, to believe? The fifth literacy advocated by Eshet Alkalai is the Socio- Emotional one.

Much of the work and information sharing done on the Internet is conducted in cooperative learning or any other form of information sharing: in chat rooms, online communities, groups and forums. Meeting of the other and Cooperative Learning necessitate socio-emotional abilities.

We came of age with the Internet. Early-adopting ,hyperconnected, always on: Call us Children of the Revolution,the first teens and tweens to grow up with the network…While other marvel at the digital future,we take it for granted . In the past,you put away childish things when you grew up . But our tools are taking over the adult world

Socio-emotional literacy

The socio-emotional literacy also has to do with the ability to tell right from wrong and good from bad: to know how to roam the web with discretion and to tell the sincere and honest person from the imposter; to spot disseminators of hatred and pedophiles, and to take precautions at the chat room and the instant messengers. This has to do with protecting oneself from the dangers of the digital, highly connected world and at the same time to guard the rights of the other by adhering to the rules of netiquette: the etiquette of the net.

I  would like to add two more literacies to the five literacies mentioned by Eshet. Moderation and Self- regulation Literacy

The new technologies have the power to carry us away. There is much talk about the addictive element of the Internet and the danger of information overload which might result in the IFS- Information Fatigue Syndrome (researched by Reuters). In order to avoid these dangers of addiction and of becoming datachoholics, we must learn and teach strategies for using the digital media with discretion and moderation.

Quality Assurance Literacy

This literacy is sort of ‘meta literacy’ as it is needed in all the other literacies. It entails first and foremost an awareness of the need and commitment for quality and excellence.

With the use of the new technologies at the tip of one’s fingers, new embellished creations can be relatively easily produced. The external beauty of PowerPoint presentations and websites might cover for the lack of quality of their content which though reliable, might be shallow. Technological mastery is no way equivalent to deep thorough thinking as many recent researches show: Miller and Almon (2003) in the USA, Fuchs and Al (2005) in Germany,  and Eshet and Hamburger (2005) in Israel. There is a dire need for quality assurance at a time when seemingly everything and anything goes.

The various literacies or strategies are interconnected and sometimes they even overlap. They function as guidelines to help us find our way in the maze of the digital-information world and to best use the immense options and possibilities this world has to offer. These literacies are needed outside the Digital Culture scene, but when it comes to the digital environment the mastery of these literacies becomes a must. Kids are great consumers of the digital media. Strangely enough they are the masters of the new  technologies.

Some Statistics

Before going into statistics it’s important to note that much of the data I am going to present comes from the American scene. However, these statistics might give us some indication as to the trends of media and especially internet usage by children and teens in other countries, especially the Western ones.  Kids are great consumers of the Digital media.

A study conducted by Knowledge Networks in 2003 “finds that a significant number of children have various media and entertainment devices in their bedrooms.” 61% of the kids who took the survey have a television set in their room 57%  said that most of their Internet access is done from their bedroom. 

Another research done by Nielsen from the end of 2003 shows that more than 2-in-10 Internet users during September 2003 were between the ages of 2 and 17.
A study from the same year run by the Indiantelevision.com team, indicates that most teenagers and young adults in the US prefer surfing the Internet or watching television over reading for recreation. Here are the figures of the Indiantelevision.com team, giving information about the number of hours teenagers spend on the various recreation activities.

Activity Hours per week
Internet surfing 16.7
Watching TV 13.6
Radio 12
Talking on phone 7.7
Reading books/magazines 6

A survey published in March 2003, conducted by Grunwald Associates (www.grunwald.com), found that 2 million American children have their own websites. The survey also predicts that the number of kids with personal sites is expected to rise to more than 6 million American children by 2005. The following table prepared by Grunwald Associates will give us some idea as to the ages of these young web masters.

Kids as Webmasters
Have Site Plan Site
Ages 6-8 4% 28%
Ages 9-12 9% 33%
Ages 3-17 15% 29%
Ages 6-17 10% 30%
Base: Kids 6-17 with home access
Source: Grunwald Associates

What influence do the Digital Media have on the wired kids?

I would like to present two opposing views as to the influence the electronic media might have on the Digital Born children. One view formulated in the eighties, is that of Neil Postman, an American philosopher. Postman deals mainly with the children of TV. Postman is wary of the new technologies. He fears that by adopting them too quickly we bring about the disappearance of childhood and destroy learning and logical-sequential thinking habits, structure and order.

The contrasting view is that of Don Tapscott, who comes from the business world. Tapscott’s view deals mainly with the children of the Internet . Tapscott believes that a new better order is emerging; he finds the Net children who master technology, to be inquisitive learners, responsible, tolerant and caring individuals.

Let’s take a closer look at Postman:

According to Postman, the world of electronic communication is a world without values, books and order. This is especially true of the world in which television reigns. Postman’s child is one who lost his childhood but never reached maturity. Postman describes a society in which children and adults watch the same movies and tele-romances (soap operas), listen to the same pop music, and play the same computer games.
The adults in such a society become more and more childish as they try to pursue the youth culture, whereas the children, to whom all the secrets of adulthood are revealed, especially  violence and sex, become, seemingly, mature. Seemingly, because they are mature externally but not emotionally.
As the differentiating line between the child and the adult blurs, concepts that distinguish the adult from the child, such as independence and responsibility, become unclear too. Postman describes a society at risk, living in a sinking world without books, without order; a chaotic meaningless world.

In his writings Postman describes children who live in a ‘twilight zone’ between illusion and reality. It is a world in which parents and teachers have lost much of their authority: Postman suggests that adults should gradually unfold the world of adulthood to their young ones. The content, the dosage and the timing should be determined by the adult, or else the very essence of childhood will disappear.

Another view of the New Child: Don Tapscott and the Net Generation

Postman places television at the center of our children’s life, and blames TV for many of the illnesses of today’s youngsters. Unlike Postman, Don Tapscott thinks of the new child as the computer-and-Internet child.
Tapscott points out that whereas the TV child maybe passive,
computer-and-Internet children are active and creative.
In his book Growing up Digital, Tapscott describes the highly
connected N-Geners: These youngsters love to learn. They are curious, inquisitive, studious and responsible. Tapscott’s children tend to learn in unorthodox ways. These high-tech children don’t necessarily study the curricula written by adults. They take responsibility over themselves and their learning, are full of initiative, and are willing to give of their knowledge to others. According to Tapscott
these digital children are caring, outspoken and aspire to
improve reality.

The Internet has become the new country of immigration. From different parts of the globe, people are coming to the new land of unlimited possibilities in which sound, music; picture, animation and text are intertwined. In lands of immigration, the young ones are the first to integrate in the new society and to speak its language. Very often they teach their parents and even grandparents the language and customs of the new land.1
This is what is happening nowadays, as the highly-connected children build sites and teach older generations the language of the high-tech.

Tapscott characterises the N-Geners as tolerant, inquisitive and eager to learn. The Oracle company harnessed this inquisitive element, to the building of subject-matter-oriented Internet sites. The company initiated a competition, geared to schoolchildren, on Internet site-building. Students have
constructed more than 5,000 such sites for students, teachers and Netizens-citizens of the net.

The N-Geners are a caring and sharing generation. They often create new Internet sites for the common good. Jason Fernandez from Mumbai in
India built such a site (
http://www.perceptivei.com/jason/jason2/LDkids/index2.htm). Jason’s site gives
support to children with learning disabilities and their parents and teachers. The site (in ten languages!) contains thorough and valuable information on various types of
learning disabilities.
When I uploaded my article on Children of the Information Age on the Internet, Jason got in touch with me via e-mail. This alone might indicate the busy life and the involvement of the youngsters on the net. I asked Jason what prompted him to build his site. He said that he learnt from the founder of Apple about the power of the individual and that the site he, Jason, built is a manifestation of his own individual power.

Three youngsters with physical disabilities set up a site (http://www.wheelg2life.info/who.htm) for other young people suffering from physical problems. This is how they explain why they took up this endeavor upon themselves:

We set this web site up for three reasons:

  • We feel the information available for young people with disabilities at the moment is too often written from an adult’s perspective.
  • Information tends to be based around one region rather than covering the country.
  • The information available assumes that every young person with a disability has a similar background.

Another characteristic of the young N-Geners is their emotional openness. There is nothing which is secret anymore, everything is read,
everything discussed, everything said. Postman would probably see this element as an indicator of the disappearance of childhood as secrets are divulged and children share and gather unscreened information on the Internet quite often without the mediating voice of the adult to
guide them.

These youngsters are not only direct and outspoken, but they are also well informed and involved in
political issues.

The N-Geners use the Net to express their opinions, independence and their protests against big companies and the controlling establishment.
The new technologies also assist us in becoming technically independent. Many of the professions held in the past solely in the hands of adults, such as printing, publishing, graphic design and others, are now at the tip of the fingers of youngsters and anyone else possessing computer skills and the ability to build Websites.

The new land, the Internet, is a mega-publishing house. Unlike traditional publishing houses where a chosen group of people decides whether a poem, a story, an essay or an article are fit to print, or a work of art fit to display, on the Net such decisions are usually not made. Everyone, regardless of age, gender or education can publish their work. The children of the Net
eagerly upload their ideas and works to the Internet.

These independent, active, innovative youngsters are about to change, according to Tapscott, our ways of learning and working and our social structure.

Computer and Internet activities outside the Net

The children of the computer and the Internet are active offline as well. They are willing to give from their vast knowledge in computers to others in face-to-face meetings.

Observing the computer-and-Internet children, one can’t help but realize that the old hierarchical structures of teachers-and-children and parents-and-children have disintegrated. In the new reality dictated in part by the new technologies we can’t expect the ‘highly-wired’ children to adhere anymore to the old rules of time and place. We, educators, can’t expect them to be satisfied with predetermined content material and subject matter. In this reality many of the concepts we teachers and educators grew up on are undergoing a major shift. The meanings of “difficult,” “easy,” “first,” “important,” “unimportant,” and “graded learning,” are changing. The teacher is accustomed to a certain order, to learning and teaching in installments. The teacher’s concepts are still based on adults’ knowledge and ideas as to what is easy and what is difficult to learn. Curricula and books are still written according to these notions.

Our N-Geners live, work and perform in a very different world which involves much doing. Their world is complex, ungraded, multi-age, interactive and dynamic. In this environment the youngsters decide for themselves what is easy and what is appropriate. The N-Geners learn and research
thoroughly that which they find interesting. They are the decision-makers as to pace, rate, content and the time element involved in the learning process.

This reversal of roles and ‘Power Shift’ presents us with a probortunity, i.e.; a problem which is really an opportunity, to re-define the purpose of education, and- to rethink our pedagogical beliefs and concepts; to reassess the theories we base our work on and whether they are appropriate to the Information Age.

We have the probortunity and the responsibility to balance: to balance the photo-visual literacy with the alphabetic literacy, to balance the almost infinite accessibility to information with tools for screening and evaluating information.

We also have the moral responsibility to be less busy with covering specific subject matter and to be more concerned about guiding our digital youngsters morally and emotionally on their voyage into the socio-emotional virtual and non-virtual space.

Futhure of Non-English Internet

International Domain Names (IDN) have become the subject of discussion at a recent press conference organised by to spread the word on the inclusion of domain names in various other languages, other than English. Imagine writing an email in Urdu, using Urdu script, an Urdu email id within an Urdu domain and receiving a reply in Hindi, with a Hindi e-mail id, Hindi domain, etc! Well, if the work being done by Afilias is completed sooner  than later, then we should see the Internet truly go international,  along with internationalised  domain names.

Emerging Trends – Shift to the East While domain names are the single  most important way to locate resources on the internet, a look at the limitations placed upon internet access by language will show that 65% of the world’s internet users don’t speak English. As the figures show, about 65% of the world falls outside the English-speaking segment. A case in point being China. In China, 90% of Internet users prefer accessing content in their local language.

However, if you look at the statistics for internet penetration, you will immediately notice that the 65%  of internet users have low penetration rates. This scenario is further  augmented by the fact that it is actually the non-English speaking regions  which contain the largest percentage of internet users as well as exhibit  the maximum growth in terms of internet users.

English                      30%
Chinese                    15%
Spanish                      9%
Japanese                   7%
French                       5%
German                     5%
Portuguese                4%
Arabic                        4%
Korean                      3%
Italian                        3%

How it works

How it works is that when you type in a URL (currently in English), your computer communicates with the ISP Provider, who in turn communicates with a root name server, which authenticates your IP address  and the URL text. The last suffix of the URL is known as a Top Level   Domain (TLD). TLDs include extensions such as:

  • .gov
  • .com
  • .in
  • .med
  • .mobi
  • .org.

Due to technical limitations, top level domain (TLD) names can only be registered  in ASCII  characters. International characters such as
those written in Hindi (Devnagari-based) cannot be interpreted by the DNS, and therefore cannot reside in a domain name registry as a  registered name.

The standard governing IDN names is known as ‘punycode’ and is an international standard that was adopted in 2003. Punycode translates words containing non-ASCII characters into an ASCII string that can be registered by the domain name registery and resolved through the DNS.

Bi-lingual keyboards, instant  messaging or chat or mobile phone text messages (SMS) are some aspects of ICT that have already started moving towards non-English formats.

However, in the case of e-mails, specialised setups are required. Also, while the text may contain native language characters, the e-mail addresses themselves are not.

Afilias is no stranger to IDN, having launched the first standards-compliant script in the .INFO domain, back in 2004. Due to the various scripts and languages used in India, plus the fact that many of them have very similar characters (22 official languages involving 12 different scripts), development of IDNs of India’s .IN domain is being worked on in  consultation with Government organisations such as, Department of Information Technology, NIXI, CDAC and ICANN. From the Government’s side, issues  such as maintaining the sovereignty (such as linking domains such as .BHARAT with .IN);

elimination of security threats such as cyber terrorism,  and of course, access to the Internet in regional  languages.

Remembering the Educational Perspective

‘Education is a lifelong process,’ I’m sure you’ve heard that old adage. But what of education in a changing landscape? Substantive investments have been made to put new era technologies in classrooms so that every citizen is equipped with the skills needed to live and work in the new Information World. However, for us in the developing world, the very mode of education May have undergone a sea change, but increasingly we are called upon to discuss the depths of the subject in terms of quality, relevance, updation and scope, to name just a few.

The road ahead is difficult and basic infrastructure issues need to be resolved alongside the move towards technology. For example, nearly 57% of Indian schools with computers are unable to use them due to lack of electricity.

While education is keystone to preparing the next generation for a knowledge-based society, it is fact that a child learns what he or she lives with. This generation of children have grown up in the presence of computer screens and have a different perspective from us. Increasingly, we find that the young around us are automatically more comfortable with technology. The Internet as a readily available source of information and method of communication has led us to new perspectives in knowledge-sharing and at the same time, brought out the need for greater discernment in terms of the methods used for assimilating information and, or knowledge. There is nothing that is secret any more, everything is read, everything  discussed and everything said, as mentioned in Edna Aphek’s article on the Implications of Education in this issue.

All this is not in isolation from the mode of education and it’s delivery mechanism. We’ve all heard it said at some point or the other that ‘the medium is the message,’  but in this case the use of ICT in the delivery of education has caused a paradigm shift. The first witnessed use of ICT was in the workplace but now ICT has  become an urgent component of education which must be woven into the very fabric of Indian society. It has also caused a paradigm shift from teacher-focused or teacher-centric education to a learner-centric one.

Research shows that children are no longer restricted to the curriculum for their inputs. Learning currently happens in almost a peer-to-peer (P2P) mode and ICT and the Internet provide the backdrop for this. Such as the example of teachers such as Pritam Singh who are using blogs to popularise interest in the subjects they teach. In such a scenario, partnerships, alliances and even a totally current phenomenon such as social networking in the Web 2.0 world  have proven themselves as the way forward. We Indians already score high in terms of social networking as it is ingrained in our culture, as is our respect for learning and learning opportunities. I wonder what Web 3.0 has in store for us next?

Ravi Gupta
Editor-in-Chief
Ravi.Gupta@csdms.in

Educational Development Index in India

Sunil Kumar Barnwal

Former State Project Director
SAarva Shiksha Abhiyan

According to ‘Flash Statistics: Elementary Education in India and Progress Towards Universal Elementary Education (2006-07)’, released by the Ministry of Human Resource Development (HRD) recently, Kerala continues to be a top achiever in composite rankings of primary and upper primary education, followed by Puducherry, Delhi and Tamil Nadu as toppers in providing elementary education. Bihar remains the state with the worst elementary education report card, while Jharkhand is second-last.

The report was based on a survey of 1.20 million schools spread over 609 districts across 35 states and union territories of India, and conducted by the National University of Educational Planning and Administration  (NUEPA) for the HRD ministry. The survey was based on the District Information System for Education (DISE) developed by NUEPA a few years ago.

“The efficiency of primary education system is directly related to the magnitude of the problem of illiteracy. So far as the school related information is concerned, the analysis should start from the indicators which give information regarding access. Information on access, should be followed by collection of information on infrastructural facilities available in a school/block/district. Other important information relate to schools need to be collected is enrolment and attendance pattern; and pattern of wastage and stagnation at different levels of schooling. While analysing efficiency of education system, different indicators of efficiency be computed separately for male/female, rural/urban, SC/ST/General population etc. so that they can help in identifying educationally weaker areas within a block/district.”       Arun C Mehta,   Professor  Educational Management  Information System, National University of Educational  Planning  and  Administration  (N U E P A)

The report tracks the progress of states towards universal elementary education at the primary and upper primary levels as well as the composite elementary level. Designed as an Educational Development Index (EDI) on which rankings are given based on 23 parameters.

The EDI has been developed keeping in mind four broad parameters—access, infrastructure, teacher related indicators and outcomes. The index takes into account 22 variables.

These variables include:

  • Access: percentage of habitations not served, availability of schools per 1000 population.
  • Infrastructure: average student-classroom ratio, school with student-classroom ratio greater than 60, school without drinking water facilities, schools with separate toilets for boys and girls as required.
  • Teachers: percentage of female teachers, pupil-teacher ratio, school with pupil-teacher ratio greater than 60, single-teacher schools-in schools with more than 15 students, percentage of schools with less than three or less teachers, teachers without professional qualification and
  • Outcome: gross enrolment ratio overall, scheduled castes: gross enrolment ratio, schedule tribes: gross enrolment ratio, gender parity index enrolment: repetition rate, drop-out rate, ratio of exit class over Class I enrolment-primary stage only, percentage of passed children to total enrolment, percentage of appeared children, passing with 60 per cent and above marks.

Though Kerala tops the combined ranking for both primary and upper primary, Delhi tops the EDI for primary sections. In primary, Delhi is followed by Puducherry and Kerala. West Bengal is placed at 30. For upper primary classes, Kerala is the topper, followed by Puducherry and Tamil Nadu.

EDI Highlights

  • Mizoram outperformed other six states in the north-eastern region
  • Puducherry is ranked 4th in case of Primary (EDI 0.65) and 2nd in Upper Primary(EDI 0.75) levels of education, and is ranked first at these levels amongst the seven smaller states
  • Kerala (EDI 0.708), Delhi (EDI 0.707), Tamil Nadu (EDI 0.701), Karnataka (EDI 0.674) and Himachal Pradesh (EDI 0.668) are the top five ranking states
  • Bihar (Rank 21), Jharkhand (Rank 20), Wes Bengal (19), Uttar Pradesh (18), Assam (17), Madhya Pradesh (16), and Orissa (15) are the seven low ranking states
  • All the 37 districts of Bihar and 15 out of 18 districts of Jahrkhand are placed in the bottom most quartile
  • All the districts of Himachal Pradesh and Sikkim are placed in the top most quartile

Bihar is the last in both the ranking, and Jharkhand is the second last in both.

Kerala had topped the chart in 2005-06 too, but this year Delhi has been replaced in the second position by Pudu-cherry in the composite ranking for both primary & upper primary. Delhi is third.

Delhi tops the EDI for primary education, followed by Puducherry and Kerala. Surprising to many would be the fact that West Bengal lags way behind, at 30 out of 35 states and union territories.

In 2005-06, Bengal ranked an abysmal 32 out of 35 states and union territories, with Arunachal Pradesh, Jharkhand and Bihar behind it. Arunachal has now swapped places with Bengal while Uttar Pradesh — that ranked 31, just ahead of Bengal last year — has hoisted itself up to 26 in the rankings.For upper primary education, Kerala is the top-ranking state, followed by Puducherry, Tamil Nadu & Chandigarh.

However, Kerala too has its problems in school education, the report reveals. While the southern state is near the top in infrastructure, teaching and student performance, access to schools is poor at both the primary (34) and the upper primary (26) levels. And access at the upper primary level is worse than in overall low-ranking Bengal , for instance. It has also failed to enrol enough numbers of Muslims who comprise nearly 25% of the state’s population, in school.

The 2006-2007 survey had an additional indicator this year, focusing on Muslim enrolment at both the primary and upper primary levels. The figures for 2006-07 show that less than 10 percent Muslims enrolled in the primary classes.The report also contains the details of SC/ST enrolment and details of districts with significant minority population and educational backwardness.

Comprising nearly 13% of India’s population, Muslim enrolment at the primary school level (Class 1-5) was a meagre 9.39% of total enrolment figures for 2006-07, while at the upper primary level (Class 6-8) it was 7.52%. All over India, about 70% of Muslim children are enrolled in primary schools; the number falls to 56% at the upper primary level.

In Orissa, Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh, Jammu and Kashmir and Puducherry, 80% of Muslim children are enrolled in school. In Orissa, Muslims make up only 2.07% of the population but total enrolment of primary and upper primary Muslims make up 7.26% and 6.48% respectively. In Karnataka, there is 13.54% enrolment of Muslims in the primary and 12.39% in the upper primary levels.

For Tamil Nadu, Delhi, Gujarat and Chhattisgarh, there is a higher enrolment percentage of Muslims in the upper primary level than in primary school. This could mean either that fewer numbers of Muslims are entering the school system than before or that Muslims’ share in the population is decreasing in these states and that this is being reflected in the enrolment figures.

States of particular concern are Kerala, Uttarakhand, Madhya Pradesh, Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, Jharkhand, Gujarat, Maharashtra, and Assam that have sizeable Muslim populations but
very low levels of Muslim enrolment
in schools.

The survey shows that the community’s access to education is poor even in states where it has a large presence, like Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, West Bengal and Kerala. Assam, Jammu and Kashmir, Andhra Pradesh and, to an extent, West Bengal are the only exceptions.

Kerala has a 24.7% Muslim population but enrolment figures for the community are abysmal – a mere 10.13% at the primary level and 9.59% at the upper primary level.

In Jammu and Kashmir , where Muslims comprise 66.97% of the population, enrolment of Muslims is 62.52% at the primary level and 60.55% in upper primary classes. And in Assam , with a 30.92% Muslim population, the community’s enrolment percentage in primary schools is a laudable 30.42% but falls significantly at the upper primary level, to 17.39%.

Orissa plays poor in EDI variables

As revealed by Flash Statistics: Elementary education in India : Progress towards UEE-2006-07, Orissa finishes a poor performer in almost all the variables – access, infrastructure, teachers and outcomes – taken to measure the Education Development Index (EDI) of the State. In 2006-07, the State recorded a dip in two parameters like access and outcomes in the primary level and in three – access, teachers and outcomes – in the upper-primary level.

In 2006-07, when nationally 6,000 more teachers have been appointed, Orissa shed 8,500. As a result, the EDI for primary slid to 0.529 and from the 29th rank in 05-06 settled at 30th out of a total of 35. Similarly, with 0.445 score in EDI for upper primary, the State figured at 32 down two from 2005-06. The State has recorded a steep fall by 21 places in the parameter of outcome, whereas in variables like accessibility it slid by four places.

Interestingly, when Orissa has Government to private school ratio at 94:6, Kerala, the top achiever, has a proportion of 42:58. When Orissa has approximately 52,000 schools in 30 districts, AP has over 1 lakh in only 23 districts. The teachers per school in Kerala hovers above 4 but it is below 3 in Orissa. Similarly, when average number of classrooms is around three in Orissa, it is over six in Kerala.It is a relative ranking, to see the state Jharkhand ranked second last in the EDI. The State is struggling with issues like school infrastructure, providing more school buildings and other facilities, providing quality education, etc. Addressing these issues and showing the progress can just not be the reflection of one year. Over a period of time such infrastructure have been created,; similarly progress in some other area can be made over a period. It’s a cumulative reflection, which cannot be reflected in the
annual EDI.

If States like Tamil Nadu or Gujarat are able to do away with these infrastructure issues, they are concentrating more on the quality issues. Jharkhand also does that. But we are continuously facing challenges on the front of some of these basic educational issues like infrastructure and quality. Just one year period cannot reverse the index, even if we progress on anything. Of course it can be improved, depending on the comparative improvement of other states. The EDI is done for all 35 states. When we try to improve, the other states are also equally improving. For improving the relative index, one needs to do it in a much faster pace. Unless we address our basic issues, that pace will probably not come.

Technology, of course, can help a lot in adding quality to education. Student today find it much more interesting and fun reading in a multimedia or an IT enabled environment. This trend helps in bringing down the drop out rates.

Mobile Education by Tata Indicom in India

Tata Teleservices is planning to start a new initiative, called Mobile Education (m-Education) to enhance distance learning and support learning in rural communities, and for the physically challenged in India.

In order to promote the education in the remotest corner of the country, the company has partnered with SNDT Women's University, ATOM Tech (Any Transaction on Mobile), and Indian PCO Teleservices (IPTL). In this alliance, SNDT University will develop and manage content, Tata Indicom on its service channels will be the carrier, ATOM will provide the intermediary interfaces, and IPTL will look after service distribution and dissemination system. Users can use the features like voice and text messages on their mobile phones to receive educational content and take mock tests on the move. The m-Education will offer contemporary content to students and do away with the need to visit physical schools and colleges, thus bridging the physical distances using CDMA technology. Initially, the m-Education service will be available in Hindi and English language. However, the alliance plans to make the service available in other regional languages later.

MCX to support Microsoft’s rural technology training programme

Multi-Commodity Exchange (MCX) of India has announced that the agency is going to support an ongoing computer literacy programme of Microsoft and Indian Society of Agribusiness Professionals in rural Maharashtra (India).

MCX has launched this social responsibility initiative to empower the youth and women of rural areas of the state with technology skills. More than 15,500 people have been trained and more than 24,000 people are using this service across 16. MCX's support will help in increasing the deployment of laptops and desktop computers, and empower the ongoing technology training and adoption efforts. The project aims to provide basic computer literacy to rural youth, farmers and women. ISAP is assisting in ground level implementation of this programme. They will install the laptops and desktop computers provided by MCX and other donors across all the centres for training.

ICT to cause new ICE age by 2020: experts

Technology specialists at the fourth annual 'Women in IT Conference' at Dubai Women's College (DWC) called the increased dependence on gadgets as the beginning of a new 'ICE Age'. This year's conference focusing on 'Green IT' was inaugurated by Shaikh Nahyan bin Mubarak Al Nahyan, Minister of Higher Education and Scientific Research.< ?xml:namespace prefix = o ns = "urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:office" />

Fariba Partawi, senior IT officer at the International Monetary Fund in Washington DC, told students at DWC, “We are drowning under the mountain of our own electronic waste. By the year 2020, 45 per cent of domestic electricity would be consumed by Information and Communications Technology (ICT) and Consumer Electronics (CE). The two combined is being called the new Ice Age.” ICE products account for two per cent of carbon emissions. Green IT is the combating of environmental challenges by responsible management of IT resources and avoiding reckless use of IT resources. Partawi observed that ICT products were pervasive as they were present everywhere and in every home had multiple devices to compound the problem.

“Each year, 125 million computers are removed from circulation and in 2006, more than 500 million phones were retired,” she said, while citing examples of companies like Xerox, Wal-Mart and Nike that were working towards cutting down on greenhouse gases. She also noted that interestingly ICT was in the unique position of controlling 98 per cent carbon emissions. Prevalent patterns of production, consumption and waste disposal of equipment have made modern technologies a major strain on the environment. This harms not only the health of the eco system, but also the health of the population. Speaking via video conference, Kim Stevenson, VP of a Texas-based company, said that emissions could be cut through the use of more efficient components and by increasing the use of power management capabilities. Experts also suggested the use of more efficient computers with increased lifespan to help the cause.

Arjun Singh releases Flash Statistics: Elementary education in India: Progress Towards UEE

The Minister for Human Resource Development of India, Arjun Singh released the Flash Statistics: Elementary Education of India: Progress towards Universal Elementary Education (UEE) 2006-07 in the meeting of Executive committee of the National Mission for SSA in the presence of Secretary, School Education & Literacy.

This time document adds the enrollment of Muslim in the primary as well as upper primary levels of education, which has been attempted for the first time in the country. This document will further help to track progress of the States towards Universal Elementary Education (UEE) for Primary and Upper Primary levels as well as for a composite look at Elementary level of Education. This exercise will help in targeting Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan (SSA) to the most needy districts. The Government is already focusing on districts with substantial population of Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Minorities and educationally backward districts. The EDI is based on four board parameters of access, infrastructure, teacher and outcomes related indicators. The index takes into account 23 variables for calculating EDI. These variables are for Access (Percentage of habitations not Served, Availability of Schools per 1000 Population and Ratio of Primary to Upper Primary Schools/Sections), Infrastructure (Average Student-Classroom Ratio, School with Student-Classroom Ratio greater > 60, School without Drinking Water Facilities, School with Boy's Toilet, School with Girl's Toilet), Teachers( (Percentage of Female Teachers, Pupil-Teacher Ratio, School with Pupil Teacher Ratio > 60, Single- Teacher Schools (in schools with more than 15 students), Percentage of Schools with 3 or less Teachers, Teachers without Professional Qualification), Outcomes (Gross Enrolment Ratio

LATEST NEWS